Why Police Agencies Outsource Background Investigations

Short-staffed investigators. Inconsistent files. Cases that drag on for months. Here's what changes when you bring in an outside team.
In most police departments, background investigations land on whoever has room on their desk that month: a detective between cases, a sergeant covering two jobs, or an HR coordinator who has never worked a background. The result is predictable. Files look different from one investigator to the next, timelines slip, and good applicants take offers from the agency down the road while yours are still waiting on a reference call.
Outsourcing doesn't take hiring out of your hands. It puts the investigative work in the hands of a team that does nothing else, so your people can get back to the jobs they were hired to do.
What Changes When You Outsource
Every file is built the same way. ProFirst investigators work from one standard process: the same records requests, reference interviews, employment and residence verification, and social media review on every applicant. When a file is ever questioned, you can show that every candidate was held to the same standard.
Your timeline becomes predictable. Our investigations typically take three to four weeks. You know when each file is coming, and you can plan academy classes and conditional offers around it.
Your staff gets their time back. Detectives go back to cases. Supervisors go back to supervising. Your recruiters spend their time recruiting, not chasing landlords and former employers.
You pay only for the investigations you need. Building a full in-house background unit means training, tools and dedicated staff, whether you're hiring five officers this year or fifty. With ProFirst, you pay per investigation, so the cost moves with your hiring instead of sitting on your budget all year.
Applicant information stays protected. A background file holds some of the most sensitive information an applicant will ever share. ProFirst handles every file confidentially, limits access to the investigators assigned to it, and delivers the completed investigation directly to your agency.
You can handle a hiring surge. When the Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department needed to process a large wave of applicants, ProFirst completed nearly 700 Nevada POST-compliant background investigations in a single year, which freed the department's internal team to focus on recruiting and community engagement.
Why It Matters: Consistency Is Your Best Defense
A background investigation is only as strong as its weakest file. Inconsistent investigations create risk under the ADA, FCRA and Title VII, especially when one applicant was looked at harder than another, or when medical and psychological steps happen out of order. Every ProFirst investigation is conducted to your state's POST standards and in compliance with FCRA, ADA and Title VII, and every finding is documented so your decision can be explained and defended.
Your Agency Keeps Every Decision
ProFirst gathers, verifies and documents the facts, and your agency makes the call. We report what we found, not whether to hire. That keeps hiring authority exactly where it belongs: with your chief, your command staff and your hiring authority.
Who We Work With
ProFirst has conducted investigations and taught in more than 20 states, for agencies ranging from small municipal departments to Las Vegas Metro. We have also developed the background investigation standard operating procedure now used by the Philadelphia Police Department's Recruitment and Background Investigation Unit. Our state-approved background investigator training has prepared more than 1,000 investigators nationwide, so we know what a defensible file looks like from both sides of the desk.
Common Questions
How long does an outsourced background investigation take?
Typically three to four weeks per applicant, depending on how quickly references, employers and records custodians respond.
Will you follow our state's POST requirements?
Yes. Every investigation is conducted to the standards of your state's POST or equivalent certifying body, along with your agency's own selection standards.
Who makes the hiring decision?
Your agency does. ProFirst documents and reports the findings; the decision stays with you.
What's included?
A full pre-employment background investigation, including a review of the applicant's public social media. VSA (Voice Stress Analysis) examinations are available on-site or remotely by secure video feed.
Can you take just part of our caseload?
Yes. Some agencies send us every file; others send us overflow during a hiring push or a hard-to-fill lateral class.
Next Step: Talk to ProFirst About Your Agency
Tell us how many applicants you expect this year and where your process gets stuck. We'll show you what an outsourced investigation looks like for your department. Contact ProFirst, or see our Police Background Investigations services.




