Lateral Police Hires: Why the Background Investigation Isn’t Already Done

Updated: 8 minutes ago
A lateral applicant walks in with a badge, a training record, and years of street experience. They’ve already passed a background investigation. They’ve already finished an academy. In a tight hiring market, it’s tempting to treat the hard part as done and move them to the front of the line.
But the background investigation they passed was done for a different agency, under that agency’s standards, sometimes a decade ago. It tells you who they were the day they were hired. It doesn’t tell you who they became on the job.
▶ WATCH THE VIDEO: click the image below to play
A Prior Background Answers a Different Question
A new recruit’s background investigation looks at how someone has lived their life. A lateral’s background investigation also has to look at how they’ve done the job: how they handled authority, complaints, discipline, and the pressure of real calls. None of that existed when their first background investigation was written. That makes a lateral background investigation more work than a recruit’s, not less.
Four Things Every Lateral Background Investigation Needs
1. The Prior Agency File
Request the full personnel and internal affairs files from every law enforcement agency the applicant has worked for, using signed releases. Ask for complaints, sustained and unsustained findings, discipline, performance evaluations, and separation paperwork. “Left in good standing” is a phrase, not a file.
2. The Real Reason They’re Leaving
Ask the applicant why they’re making the move, then verify the answer. Talk to former supervisors and field training officers, not just HR. A resignation that happened in the middle of an investigation tells a very different story than one that came with a going-away cake.
Keep in mind that the prior agency isn’t always a neutral reference. An agency that would be happy to see a problem employee leave may offer glowing verbal praise to help them out the door. And command staff who don’t want to lose a good officer, or start another recruitment, may be less than enthusiastic in the hope the officer stays put. Either way, the phone call tells you what someone wants you to hear. That’s why the written record matters most: weigh what people say against the personnel file, the internal affairs history, and the documents, and follow up on anything that doesn’t line up.
3. Decertification Records
Check the applicant’s certification status with every state where they’ve held a law enforcement certification, and query the National Decertification Index (NDI). The NDI is a free national registry of officer certification revocations, maintained by the International Association of Directors of Law Enforcement Standards and Training (IADLEST). Agencies request access through their state POST. Two cautions apply. The NDI is a pointer system, so any match must be verified with the state that reported it. And states don’t all report the same way, so a clean NDI result doesn’t replace the prior agency file. Some states now require it: Texas, for example, requires agencies to use the NDI as part of the pre-employment background investigation.
4. The Full Standard, Every Time
Run the same complete investigation you’d run on a brand-new recruit: employment history, references, criminal and financial history, residence and neighbor interviews, and a social media review. Applying one standard to every applicant is what makes a hiring decision defensible. It’s the same principle behind written police selection standards.
Experience Is Valuable. It Isn’t a Shortcut.
A good lateral can be the best hire you make all year. They bring street experience, they shorten your training timeline, and they often mentor newer officers. That’s exactly why the file needs to prove it. If a lateral hire ever goes wrong, the first question will be what your agency knew, or could have known, before the offer went out.
How ProFirst Helps
ProFirst’s experienced investigators complete thorough, consistent police background investigations for lateral, entry-level, and civilian positions. Applicants are guided through a secure background investigation portal. For laterals, that means the prior agency records, a verified separation history, decertification records, and the full investigation, documented so the file holds up if a hiring decision is ever challenged.
Weighing whether to bring in outside help? Read why police agencies outsource background investigations.
Hiring laterals this cycle? Talk to ProFirst about getting those background investigations done right, and on time. Talk to ProFirst →



